Methane in NEEM-2011-S1 ice core from North Greenland, 1800 years continuous record: Version 2

doi:doi:10.1594/PANGAEA.899040

Methane in NEEM-2011-S1 ice core from North Greenland, 1800 years continuous record: Version 2

Changes to original version posted at NOAA (https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo-search/study/14173): Chronology has been updated to most recent NEEM-2011-S1 ice age and NEEM delta age. Age scale now constructed from annual-layer-counted ice age (Sigl et al., 2015, Nature). Two options for delta age provided a) constant delta age of 188 yr (Buizert et al. 2012, ACP & 2014 corrigendum), b) variable delta age transferred from main NEEM core (Rasmussen et al., 2013, COP) using offsets between GICC05 and NEEM-2011-S1 ice age provided by Sigl et al. 2015. Outliers at 387.2-387.4 m and 335.1-335.3 m depth removed.

Publication abstract: Ancient air trapped inside bubbles in ice cores can now be analysed for methane concentration utilising a laser spectrometer coupled to a continuous melter system. We present a new ultra-high resolution record of atmospheric methane variability over the last 1800 yr obtained from continuous analysis of a shallow ice core from the North Greenland Eemian project (NEEM-2011-S1) during a 4-week laboratory-based measurement campaign. Our record faithfully replicates the form and amplitudes of multi-decadal oscillations previously observed in other ice cores and demonstrates the detailed depth resolution (5.3 cm), rapid acquisition time (30 m day-1) and good long-term reproducibility (2.6%, 2s) of the continuous measurement technique. In addition, we report the detection of high frequency ice core methane signals of non-atmospheric origin. Firstly, measurements of air from the firn-ice transition region and an interval of ice core dating from 1546-1560 AD (gas age) resolve apparently quasi-annual scale methane oscillations. Traditional gas chromatography measurements on discrete ice samples confirm these signals and indicate peak-topeak amplitudes of ca. 22 parts per billion (ppb). We hypothesise that these oscillations result from staggered bubble close-off between seasonal layers of contrasting density during time periods of sustained multi-year atmospheric methane change. Secondly, we report the detection of abrupt (20-100 cm depth interval), high amplitude (35-80 ppb excess) methane spikes in the NEEM ice that are reproduced by discrete measurements. We show for the first time that methane spikes present in thin and infrequent layers in polar, glacial ice are accompanied by elevated concentrations of carbon and nitrogen-based chemical impurities, and suggest that biological in-situ production may be responsible.

Funding: US National Science Foundation, Grant: 0944552, 0909541, 0968391 ANR France, Grant: ANR-10-RPDOC-002-01, ANR-07-VULN-09-001 * European Research Council, Grant: FP7/2007-2013 Grant Agreement 291062

BibTex:

@dataset{Rhodes_Rachael_H_and_Brook_Edward_J_2019,
    abstract = {Changes to original version posted at NOAA (https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo-search/study/14173):  Chronology has been updated to most recent NEEM-2011-S1 ice age and NEEM delta age. Age scale now constructed from annual-layer-counted ice age (Sigl et al., 2015, Nature). Two options for delta age provided a) constant delta age of 188 yr (Buizert et al. 2012, ACP & 2014 corrigendum), b) variable delta age transferred from main NEEM core (Rasmussen et al., 2013, COP) using offsets between GICC05 and NEEM-2011-S1 ice age provided by Sigl et al. 2015.  Outliers at 387.2-387.4 m and 335.1-335.3 m depth removed.

Publication abstract: 
Ancient air trapped inside bubbles in ice cores can now be analysed for methane concentration utilising a laser spectrometer coupled to a continuous melter system. We present a new ultra-high resolution record of atmospheric methane variability over the last 1800 yr obtained from continuous analysis of a shallow ice core from the North Greenland Eemian project (NEEM-2011-S1) during a 4-week laboratory-based measurement campaign. Our record faithfully replicates the form and amplitudes of multi-decadal oscillations previously observed in other ice cores and demonstrates the detailed depth resolution (5.3 cm), rapid acquisition time (30 m day-1) and good long-term reproducibility (2.6%, 2s) of the continuous measurement technique.
In addition, we report the detection of high frequency ice core methane signals of non-atmospheric origin. Firstly, measurements of air from the firn-ice transition region and an interval of ice core dating from 1546-1560 AD (gas age) resolve apparently quasi-annual scale methane oscillations. Traditional gas chromatography measurements on discrete ice samples confirm these signals and indicate peak-topeak amplitudes of ca. 22 parts per billion (ppb). We hypothesise that these oscillations result from staggered bubble close-off between seasonal layers of contrasting density during time periods of sustained multi-year atmospheric methane change. Secondly, we report the detection of abrupt (20-100 cm depth interval), high amplitude (35-80 ppb excess) methane spikes in the NEEM ice that are reproduced by discrete measurements. We show for the first time that methane spikes present in thin and infrequent layers in polar, glacial ice are accompanied by elevated concentrations of carbon and nitrogen-based chemical impurities, and suggest that biological in-situ production may be responsible.

Funding: 
* US National Science Foundation, Grant: 0944552, 0909541, 0968391
* ANR France, Grant: ANR-10-RPDOC-002-01, ANR-07-VULN-09-001
* European Research Council, Grant: FP7/2007-2013 Grant Agreement 291062},
    author = {Rhodes, Rachael H and Brook, Edward J},
    doi = {10.1594/PANGAEA.899040},
    institution = {PANGAEA (Geophysics)},
    keyword = {'Greenland', 'Holocene', 'Ice core', 'Methane', 'atmospheric composition', 'biogeochemical cycles'},
    title = {Methane in NEEM-2011-S1 ice core from North Greenland, 1800 years continuous record: Version 2},
    url = {https://service.tib.eu/ldmservice/vdataset/png-doi-10-1594-pangaea-899040},
    year = {2019}
}