Global compilation of stable carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotope values of meso- and bathypelagic fish

Stable isotope analysis (SIA) has emerged as a valuable tool for understanding the trophic structure of the marine food web and gaining insights into trophic levels and niche. Researchers are increasingly utilizing SIA in studies focused on feeding ecology, particularly in estimating the long-term diets of meso- and bathypelagic fish. To facilitate this research, a global database of published data on stable isotopes, specifically δ13C and δ15N, of meso- and bathypelagic fish was created. The database was constructed by conducting a thorough search on Google Scholar and reviewing the references cited in the retrieved papers. The search primarily involved using popular terms such as stable isotope analysis or feeding ecology in combination with mesopelagic or bathypelagic fish. The resulting SIA database contains δ13C and δ15N values for 95 different species of meso- and bathypelagic fish, belonging to 27 families, with specimens collected between 2004 and 2015. Each entry in the database includes information on the sampling location, month and year of sample collection, taxonomic classifications (phylum, class, order, family), number of samples analyzed, as well as the reference and DOI of the original data source. This global SIA database holds significant potential as a valuable tool and data source for conducting large-scale meta-analyses.

Data and Resources

This dataset has no data

Cite this as

Papadimitraki, Maria, Jónasdóttir, Sigrún Huld (2023). Dataset: Global compilation of stable carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotope values of meso- and bathypelagic fish. https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.962977

DOI retrieved: 2023

Additional Info

Field Value
Imported on November 30, 2024
Last update November 30, 2024
License CC-BY-4.0
Source https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.962977
Author Papadimitraki, Maria
Given Name Maria
Family Name Papadimitraki
More Authors
Jónasdóttir, Sigrún Huld
Source Creation 2023
Publication Year 2023
Resource Type text/tab-separated-values - filename: Papadimitraki-etal_2023
Subject Areas
Name: BiologicalClassification

Name: Oceans

Related Identifiers
Title: Meso- and bathypelagic fish feeding ecology: A meta-analysis on fatty acids and stable isotope trophic studies
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dsr.2023.104083
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2023
Source: Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Isotopic niches and trophic levels of myctophid fishes and their predators in the Southern Ocean
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.4319/lo.2010.55.1.0324
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2010
Source: Limnology and Oceanography
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Trophodynamic studies on the Condor seamount (Azores, Portugal, North Atlantic)
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dsr2.2013.01.010
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2013
Source: Deep Sea Research Part II: Topical Studies in Oceanography
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Food web structure of deep-sea macrozooplankton and micronekton off the Catalan slope: Insight from stable isotopes
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmarsys.2011.03.003
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2011
Source: Journal of Marine Systems
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Trophic ecology of Lampanyctus crocodilus on north-west Mediterranean Sea slopes in relation to reproductive cycle and environmental variables
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1111/jfb.12378
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2014
Source: Journal of Fish Biology
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Trophic structure of mesopelagic fishes in the Gulf of Mexico revealed by gut content and stable isotope analyses
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1111/maec.12449
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2017
Source: Marine Ecology
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Trophic position of lanternfishes (Pisces: Myctophidae) of the tropical and equatorial Atlantic estimated using stable isotopes
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fsx243
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2019
Source: ICES Journal of Marine Science
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Trophic interactions of the pelagic ecosystem over the Reykjanes Ridge as evaluated by fatty acid and stable isotope analyses
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dsr2.2007.09.003
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2008
Source: Deep Sea Research Part II: Topical Studies in Oceanography
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Trophic ecology of meso- and bathypelagic predatory fishes in the Gulf of Mexico
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fsy074
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2019
Source: ICES Journal of Marine Science
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Compilation of stable nitrogen and carbon isotope ratios of marine biota from the central and Northeast Atlantic, and the Mediterranean Sea
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.945917
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2022
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Food web dynamics in the Scotia Sea in summer: A stable isotope study
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dsr2.2011.08.004
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2012
Source: Deep Sea Research Part II: Topical Studies in Oceanography
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Trophic structure of mesopelagic fishes in the western Mediterranean based on stable isotopes of carbon and nitrogen
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmarsys.2014.04.007
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2014
Source: Journal of Marine Systems
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .

Title: Trophic Interactions of Mesopelagic Fishes in the South China Sea Illustrated by Stable Isotopes and Fatty Acids
Identifier: https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2018.00522
Type: DOI
Relation: References
Year: 2019
Source: Frontiers in Marine Science
Authors: Papadimitraki Maria , Maar Kristian , Jónasdóttir Sigrún Huld , Cherel Yves , Fontaine Camille , Richard Pierre , Labatc Jean-Philippe , Colaço Ana , Giacomello Eva , Porteiro Filipe , Menezes Gui M , Fanelli Emanuela , Cartes Joan E , Papiol V , Fanelli Emanuela , Papiol V , Cartes Joan E , Rodriguez-Romeu O , McClain-Counts Jennifer , Demopoulos Amanda W J , Ross Steve W , Olivar M Pilar , Bode Antonio , López-Pérez Cristina , Hulley P Alexander , Hernández-León Santiago , Petursdottir Hildur , Gislason Astthor , Falk-Petersen Stig , Hop Haakon , Svavarsson Jörundur , Richards Travis M , Gipson Emily E , Cook April , Sutton Tracey T , Wells R J D , Silva Mónica A , Olivar M Pilar , Bernal Ainhoa , Colaço Ana , Chouvelon Tiphaine , Spitz Jérôme , Fonseca Catarina T , Pérez-Jorge Sergi , Stowasser Gabriele , Atkinson Angus , McGill Rona A R , Phillips Richard A , Collins Martin A , Pond David W , Valls Maria , Olivar M Pilar , Fernández de Puelles Maria Luz , Molí Balbina , Bernal Ainhoa , Sweeting C J , Wang Fuqiang , Wu Ying , Chen Zuozhi , Zhang Guosen , Zhang Jun , Zheng Shan , Kattner Gerhard .